# National BIA appeal dispositions

Complete disposition FY2021–FY2025, nationally, for all recorded filing parties, respondent-filed (A), and DHS-filed (I). Each annual scope keeps its own denominator. Query parameters are not supported.

Recorded IJ Case Appeal events, not people, unique cases, or final asylum outcomes. The fiscal year is the disposition year, not the filing year.

[HTML](https://asylumcompass.com/bia) · [JSON](https://asylumcompass.com/bia.json) · [Schema](https://asylumcompass.com/schemas/collection-response-v1.json)

A metric combines its definition with the row’s filing party, disposition period, population ID, sourceRef and provenanceId. Summary n sums only the five published annual denominators in that same filing-party scope.

All includes Both and Other filing-party codes; all is not A + I. A and I each use their own annual n.

For each outcome, percent = 100 × outcome count / the same row’s n. Numeric shares retain unrounded values and raw operands; HTML percentages use one decimal place, half-expand rounding. Rounded shares may not sum to 100%. A zero denominator is not calculable.

DIS is the documented dismissal/affirmance code. It does not establish a final asylum denial.

REM returns the matter for further proceedings or action. It is not an asylum grant or a known final result.

SUS records that an appeal was sustained. Which party filed matters; it is not a universal respondent win.

Other is a mixed group of recorded codes, including summary dismissal, summary affirmance and administrative pathways.

Source states remain distinct: visible (published positive count), zero (real zero), suppressed (withheld by source), missing, unmatched, not_applicable, and unknown. Missing is never filled with zero; nonnumeric operands produce no numeric share. This public-source edition does not apply a site small-cell mask.

| Metric ID | Meaning | Unit | Formula | Denominator | Precision / rounding |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| n | Appeal events (denominator) | appeal_events | — | — | 0 / none |
| DIS | Dismissed / IJ decision affirmed (DIS), as recorded | appeal_events | — | — | 0 / none |
| REM | Remanded for further action (REM), as recorded | appeal_events | — | — | 0 / none |
| SUS | Appeal sustained (SUS), as recorded | appeal_events | — | — | 0 / none |
| Other | Other recorded dispositions | appeal_events | — | — | 0 / none |
| DIS_share | Dismissed / IJ decision affirmed (DIS), as recorded | percent | 100*outcome_count/same_row_n | same_disposition_fy_and_filing_party_n | 1 / halfExpand |
| REM_share | Remanded for further action (REM), as recorded | percent | 100*outcome_count/same_row_n | same_disposition_fy_and_filing_party_n | 1 / halfExpand |
| SUS_share | Appeal sustained (SUS), as recorded | percent | 100*outcome_count/same_row_n | same_disposition_fy_and_filing_party_n | 1 / halfExpand |
| Other_share | Other recorded dispositions | percent | 100*outcome_count/same_row_n | same_disposition_fy_and_filing_party_n | 1 / halfExpand |

## all:FY2021

party=all; 2020-10-01 – 2021-09-30; basis=disposition_fiscal_year; isPartial=false; populationId=bia-decided-1; sourceRef=bia-national; provenanceId=national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{"fy":2021}

n: 18502; state=visible appeal_events

| Outcome | Count (appeal_events) | Percent / state / reason | Raw numerator / denominator |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| DIS | 10087; state=visible | 54.51843043995244; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 10087; state=visible; denominator: 18502; state=visible |
| REM | 4600; state=visible | 24.86217706193925; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 4600; state=visible; denominator: 18502; state=visible |
| SUS | 82; state=visible | 0.44319533023456925; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 82; state=visible; denominator: 18502; state=visible |
| Other | 3733; state=visible | 20.17619716787374; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 3733; state=visible; denominator: 18502; state=visible |

## all:FY2022

party=all; 2021-10-01 – 2022-09-30; basis=disposition_fiscal_year; isPartial=false; populationId=bia-decided-1; sourceRef=bia-national; provenanceId=national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{"fy":2022}

n: 19919; state=visible appeal_events

| Outcome | Count (appeal_events) | Percent / state / reason | Raw numerator / denominator |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| DIS | 9629; state=visible | 48.34078015964657; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 9629; state=visible; denominator: 19919; state=visible |
| REM | 4462; state=visible | 22.400722927857824; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 4462; state=visible; denominator: 19919; state=visible |
| SUS | 54; state=visible | 0.2710979466840705; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 54; state=visible; denominator: 19919; state=visible |
| Other | 5774; state=visible | 28.987398965811536; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 5774; state=visible; denominator: 19919; state=visible |

## all:FY2023

party=all; 2022-10-01 – 2023-09-30; basis=disposition_fiscal_year; isPartial=false; populationId=bia-decided-1; sourceRef=bia-national; provenanceId=national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{"fy":2023}

n: 23597; state=visible appeal_events

| Outcome | Count (appeal_events) | Percent / state / reason | Raw numerator / denominator |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| DIS | 12939; state=visible | 54.83324151375175; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 12939; state=visible; denominator: 23597; state=visible |
| REM | 3766; state=visible | 15.959655888460398; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 3766; state=visible; denominator: 23597; state=visible |
| SUS | 48; state=visible | 0.20341568843497054; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 48; state=visible; denominator: 23597; state=visible |
| Other | 6844; state=visible | 29.003686909352883; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 6844; state=visible; denominator: 23597; state=visible |

## all:FY2024

party=all; 2023-10-01 – 2024-09-30; basis=disposition_fiscal_year; isPartial=false; populationId=bia-decided-1; sourceRef=bia-national; provenanceId=national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{"fy":2024}

n: 33160; state=visible appeal_events

| Outcome | Count (appeal_events) | Percent / state / reason | Raw numerator / denominator |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| DIS | 18794; state=visible | 56.6767189384801; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 18794; state=visible; denominator: 33160; state=visible |
| REM | 3753; state=visible | 11.317852834740652; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 3753; state=visible; denominator: 33160; state=visible |
| SUS | 45; state=visible | 0.13570566948130278; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 45; state=visible; denominator: 33160; state=visible |
| Other | 10568; state=visible | 31.869722557297948; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 10568; state=visible; denominator: 33160; state=visible |

## all:FY2025

party=all; 2024-10-01 – 2025-09-30; basis=disposition_fiscal_year; isPartial=false; populationId=bia-decided-1; sourceRef=bia-national; provenanceId=national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{"fy":2025}

n: 24074; state=visible appeal_events

| Outcome | Count (appeal_events) | Percent / state / reason | Raw numerator / denominator |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| DIS | 11978; state=visible | 49.75492232283791; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 11978; state=visible; denominator: 24074; state=visible |
| REM | 3213; state=visible | 13.346348757996179; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 3213; state=visible; denominator: 24074; state=visible |
| SUS | 81; state=visible | 0.3364625737309961; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 81; state=visible; denominator: 24074; state=visible |
| Other | 8802; state=visible | 36.56226634543491; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 8802; state=visible; denominator: 24074; state=visible |

## A:FY2021

party=A; 2020-10-01 – 2021-09-30; basis=disposition_fiscal_year; isPartial=false; populationId=bia-respondent-decided-1; sourceRef=bia-national; provenanceId=national:bia-respondent-decided-1:disposition_fy:{"fy":2021,"party":"A"}

n: 15234; state=visible appeal_events

| Outcome | Count (appeal_events) | Percent / state / reason | Raw numerator / denominator |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| DIS | 9983; state=visible | 65.53104896941053; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 9983; state=visible; denominator: 15234; state=visible |
| REM | 1745; state=visible | 11.454640934751215; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 1745; state=visible; denominator: 15234; state=visible |
| SUS | 7; state=visible | 0.045949849021924644; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 7; state=visible; denominator: 15234; state=visible |
| Other | 3499; state=visible | 22.96836024681633; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 3499; state=visible; denominator: 15234; state=visible |

## A:FY2022

party=A; 2021-10-01 – 2022-09-30; basis=disposition_fiscal_year; isPartial=false; populationId=bia-respondent-decided-1; sourceRef=bia-national; provenanceId=national:bia-respondent-decided-1:disposition_fy:{"fy":2022,"party":"A"}

n: 18012; state=visible appeal_events

| Outcome | Count (appeal_events) | Percent / state / reason | Raw numerator / denominator |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| DIS | 9587; state=visible | 53.22562735953809; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 9587; state=visible; denominator: 18012; state=visible |
| REM | 3615; state=visible | 20.069953364423718; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 3615; state=visible; denominator: 18012; state=visible |
| SUS | 2; state=visible | 0.01110370863868532; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 2; state=visible; denominator: 18012; state=visible |
| Other | 4808; state=visible | 26.693315567399512; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 4808; state=visible; denominator: 18012; state=visible |

## A:FY2023

party=A; 2022-10-01 – 2023-09-30; basis=disposition_fiscal_year; isPartial=false; populationId=bia-respondent-decided-1; sourceRef=bia-national; provenanceId=national:bia-respondent-decided-1:disposition_fy:{"fy":2023,"party":"A"}

n: 22668; state=visible appeal_events

| Outcome | Count (appeal_events) | Percent / state / reason | Raw numerator / denominator |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| DIS | 12874; state=visible | 56.793718016587256; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 12874; state=visible; denominator: 22668; state=visible |
| REM | 3204; state=visible | 14.13446267866596; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 3204; state=visible; denominator: 22668; state=visible |
| SUS | 1; state=visible | 0.0044115052055761425; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 1; state=visible; denominator: 22668; state=visible |
| Other | 6589; state=visible | 29.067407799541204; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 6589; state=visible; denominator: 22668; state=visible |

## A:FY2024

party=A; 2023-10-01 – 2024-09-30; basis=disposition_fiscal_year; isPartial=false; populationId=bia-respondent-decided-1; sourceRef=bia-national; provenanceId=national:bia-respondent-decided-1:disposition_fy:{"fy":2024,"party":"A"}

n: 32318; state=visible appeal_events

| Outcome | Count (appeal_events) | Percent / state / reason | Raw numerator / denominator |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| DIS | 18736; state=visible | 57.973884522557086; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 18736; state=visible; denominator: 32318; state=visible |
| REM | 3269; state=visible | 10.115106132805249; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 3269; state=visible; denominator: 32318; state=visible |
| SUS | 2; state=visible | 0.006188501763723002; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 2; state=visible; denominator: 32318; state=visible |
| Other | 10311; state=visible | 31.90482084287394; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 10311; state=visible; denominator: 32318; state=visible |

## A:FY2025

party=A; 2024-10-01 – 2025-09-30; basis=disposition_fiscal_year; isPartial=false; populationId=bia-respondent-decided-1; sourceRef=bia-national; provenanceId=national:bia-respondent-decided-1:disposition_fy:{"fy":2025,"party":"A"}

n: 21763; state=visible appeal_events

| Outcome | Count (appeal_events) | Percent / state / reason | Raw numerator / denominator |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| DIS | 11793; state=visible | 54.188301245232736; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 11793; state=visible; denominator: 21763; state=visible |
| REM | 1640; state=visible | 7.535725773101135; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 1640; state=visible; denominator: 21763; state=visible |
| SUS | 7; state=visible | 0.0321646831778707; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 7; state=visible; denominator: 21763; state=visible |
| Other | 8323; state=visible | 38.24380829848826; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 8323; state=visible; denominator: 21763; state=visible |

## I:FY2021

party=I; 2020-10-01 – 2021-09-30; basis=disposition_fiscal_year; isPartial=false; populationId=bia-decided-1; sourceRef=bia-national; provenanceId=national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{"fy":2021,"party":"I"}

n: 3188; state=visible appeal_events

| Outcome | Count (appeal_events) | Percent / state / reason | Raw numerator / denominator |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| DIS | 80; state=visible | 2.5094102885821834; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 80; state=visible; denominator: 3188; state=visible |
| REM | 2814; state=visible | 88.2685069008783; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 2814; state=visible; denominator: 3188; state=visible |
| SUS | 71; state=visible | 2.2271016311166876; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 71; state=visible; denominator: 3188; state=visible |
| Other | 223; state=visible | 6.994981179422836; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 223; state=visible; denominator: 3188; state=visible |

## I:FY2022

party=I; 2021-10-01 – 2022-09-30; basis=disposition_fiscal_year; isPartial=false; populationId=bia-decided-1; sourceRef=bia-national; provenanceId=national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{"fy":2022,"party":"I"}

n: 1840; state=visible appeal_events

| Outcome | Count (appeal_events) | Percent / state / reason | Raw numerator / denominator |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| DIS | 37; state=visible | 2.010869565217391; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 37; state=visible; denominator: 1840; state=visible |
| REM | 814; state=visible | 44.23913043478261; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 814; state=visible; denominator: 1840; state=visible |
| SUS | 47; state=visible | 2.5543478260869565; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 47; state=visible; denominator: 1840; state=visible |
| Other | 942; state=visible | 51.19565217391305; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 942; state=visible; denominator: 1840; state=visible |

## I:FY2023

party=I; 2022-10-01 – 2023-09-30; basis=disposition_fiscal_year; isPartial=false; populationId=bia-decided-1; sourceRef=bia-national; provenanceId=national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{"fy":2023,"party":"I"}

n: 892; state=visible appeal_events

| Outcome | Count (appeal_events) | Percent / state / reason | Raw numerator / denominator |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| DIS | 56; state=visible | 6.278026905829597; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 56; state=visible; denominator: 892; state=visible |
| REM | 540; state=visible | 60.53811659192825; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 540; state=visible; denominator: 892; state=visible |
| SUS | 46; state=visible | 5.15695067264574; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 46; state=visible; denominator: 892; state=visible |
| Other | 250; state=visible | 28.026905829596412; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 250; state=visible; denominator: 892; state=visible |

## I:FY2024

party=I; 2023-10-01 – 2024-09-30; basis=disposition_fiscal_year; isPartial=false; populationId=bia-decided-1; sourceRef=bia-national; provenanceId=national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{"fy":2024,"party":"I"}

n: 813; state=visible appeal_events

| Outcome | Count (appeal_events) | Percent / state / reason | Raw numerator / denominator |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| DIS | 53; state=visible | 6.519065190651906; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 53; state=visible; denominator: 813; state=visible |
| REM | 465; state=visible | 57.19557195571956; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 465; state=visible; denominator: 813; state=visible |
| SUS | 42; state=visible | 5.166051660516605; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 42; state=visible; denominator: 813; state=visible |
| Other | 253; state=visible | 31.11931119311193; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 253; state=visible; denominator: 813; state=visible |

## I:FY2025

party=I; 2024-10-01 – 2025-09-30; basis=disposition_fiscal_year; isPartial=false; populationId=bia-decided-1; sourceRef=bia-national; provenanceId=national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{"fy":2025,"party":"I"}

n: 2258; state=visible appeal_events

| Outcome | Count (appeal_events) | Percent / state / reason | Raw numerator / denominator |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| DIS | 172; state=visible | 7.617360496014172; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 172; state=visible; denominator: 2258; state=visible |
| REM | 1545; state=visible | 68.42338352524358; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 1545; state=visible; denominator: 2258; state=visible |
| SUS | 68; state=visible | 3.011514614703277; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 68; state=visible; denominator: 2258; state=visible |
| Other | 473; state=visible | 20.947741364038972; state=visible; reason=— | numerator: 473; state=visible; denominator: 2258; state=visible |

## Published five-year denominators

- all: All recorded filing parties; n=119252; state=visible appeal_events; all:FY2021, all:FY2022, all:FY2023, all:FY2024, all:FY2025; formula=sum(same_party_annual_n); sourceRef=bia-national
- A: Respondent-filed appeals (A); n=109995; state=visible appeal_events; A:FY2021, A:FY2022, A:FY2023, A:FY2024, A:FY2025; formula=sum(same_party_annual_n); sourceRef=bia-national
- I: DHS-filed appeals (I); n=8991; state=visible appeal_events; I:FY2021, I:FY2022, I:FY2023, I:FY2024, I:FY2025; formula=sum(same_party_annual_n); sourceRef=bia-national

## Sources, methods and citation

- [method](https://asylumcompass.com/bia-methodology)
- [codebook](https://asylumcompass.com/bia-methodology#bia-codebook)
- [sources](https://asylumcompass.com/sources#bia-case-data)
- [courts](https://asylumcompass.com/courts)
- [nationalities](https://asylumcompass.com/nationalities)
- [officialWorkload](https://www.justice.gov/eoir/media/1344986/dl?inline=)

- id: bia-national
- releaseId: eoir-2026-08-bia-public-national-v1
- baseReleaseId: eoir-2026-08-court-dispositions-v5
- payloadUrl: https://asylumcompass.com/data/bia/eoir-2026-08-bia-public-national-v1/bia-national.json
- payloadSha256: b242d7073077234289a5a5c5faf07c65c19bcd4a55537b47f458172db86cb207
- manifestUrl: https://asylumcompass.com/data/bia/eoir-2026-08-bia-public-national-v1/manifest.json
- manifestSha256: 005ce41913ec92a03eabb0dbc343950a5050da0fcf59a2ae6790910e197750c4
- baseManifestUrl: https://asylumcompass.com/data/eoir-2026-08-court-dispositions-v5/manifest.json
- baseManifestSha256: 9d690e1de906d44cd9b1f72748f099695a1298726a4ab1c15b8905d051ec961a
- officialUrl: https://fileshare.eoir.justice.gov/EOIR%20Case%20Data.zip
- sourceSha256: 0a409ce1b175532df7bb2f0c58d06dd20fa6b4d904d749fde7df1b038ac498e2
- sourceSnapshot: 2026-08
- dataThrough: 2026-08-31
- releaseBuiltAt: 2026-10-12T04:54:29.350029+00:00
- publicationDate: {"state":"unknown","reason":"not_separately_listed"}
- populationVersion: BIA1.0.0
- disclosureVersion: verified-public-counts-1
- contractVersion: bia-public-source-aggregate-1
- contractSha256: 004ba5c87e7d681c47a9a97a1247e70b25ab2b141cb0d4a75f7bdfdaa348f86a
- definitionContracts: {"contracts/bia-v1-2026-08.json":"98579cc86aa15a9c7f7ff0d35aead084e318e757f4eeaa95c7f1c405a71e15de","contracts/bia-v1-court-phase2a-2026-08.json":"706d5296992b130879aa23dffb11efda2ad2c17ebefc55a6e9986c0e1c9b7c5e","contracts/bia-v1-judge-phase2c-2026-08.json":"04ca292a23fd9ffc7b1147828b2820e67d00607603590375b489759704350b39","contracts/bia-v1-nationality-phase2b-2026-08.json":"223da0585e9f3187046ae2ae4091d167d29c7613b85c688f21656b82aca960b6","contracts/bia-v1-phase1-2026-08.json":"b2777bc4f12448ab81eeb93bfc88b3dbb8b6de6f8d2ec01f7c3cfcbb70e27b96"}
- validationBoundary: Validation checks the fixed published aggregate and its manifest and contracts; it does not reprocess underlying appeal records. Snapshot, cutoff, release build time and content revision are separate. A separate publication date is not listed.

Official all-appeals workload covers a different population and cannot supply the denominator for these CASE IJ Case Appeal dispositions. Its numeric series, filing/followup and duration quantiles are outside this collection.

Historical court or judge code associations do not establish that the court or judge made the BIA decision. These records do not predict individual outcomes or establish causes.

Validation checks the fixed published aggregate and its manifest and contracts; it does not reprocess underlying appeal records. Snapshot, cutoff, release build time and content revision are separate. A separate publication date is not listed.

title=National BIA appeal dispositions; url=https://asylumcompass.com/bia; period=FY2021–FY2025; timeBasis=disposition_fiscal_year; parties=all,A,I; sourceReleaseId=eoir-2026-08-bia-public-national-v1; dataThrough=2026-08-31; contentRevision=2026-10-15

```json
{"schema":"asylumcompass-collection-response-1","ok":true,"publication":{"schema":"asylumcompass-bia-collection-publication-1","resourceId":"eoir:collection:bia","collection":"bia","locale":"en","title":"National BIA appeal dispositions","canonicalUrl":"https://asylumcompass.com/bia","representationUrl":"https://asylumcompass.com/bia.json","scope":{"kind":"national_bia_disposition_fiscal_years","parameters":[],"explanation":"Complete disposition FY2021–FY2025, nationally, for all recorded filing parties, respondent-filed (A), and DHS-filed (I). Each annual scope keeps its own denominator. Query parameters are not supported."},"unit":"appeal_events","unitDefinition":"Recorded IJ Case Appeal events, not people, unique cases, or final asylum outcomes. The fiscal year is the disposition year, not the filing year.","methodNotes":["All includes Both and Other filing-party codes; all is not A + I. A and I each use their own annual n.","For each outcome, percent = 100 × outcome count / the same row’s n. Numeric shares retain unrounded values and raw operands; HTML percentages use one decimal place, half-expand rounding. Rounded shares may not sum to 100%. A zero denominator is not calculable.","DIS is the documented dismissal/affirmance code. It does not establish a final asylum denial.","REM returns the matter for further proceedings or action. It is not an asylum grant or a known final result.","SUS records that an appeal was sustained. Which party filed matters; it is not a universal respondent win.","Other is a mixed group of recorded codes, including summary dismissal, summary affirmance and administrative pathways."],"metricDefinitions":[{"id":"n","label":"Appeal events (denominator)","unit":"appeal_events","formula":null,"denominatorDefinition":null,"displayPrecision":0,"rounding":"none","methodUrl":"https://asylumcompass.com/bia-methodology"},{"id":"DIS","label":"Dismissed / IJ decision affirmed (DIS), as recorded","unit":"appeal_events","formula":null,"denominatorDefinition":null,"displayPrecision":0,"rounding":"none","methodUrl":"https://asylumcompass.com/bia-methodology"},{"id":"REM","label":"Remanded for further action (REM), as recorded","unit":"appeal_events","formula":null,"denominatorDefinition":null,"displayPrecision":0,"rounding":"none","methodUrl":"https://asylumcompass.com/bia-methodology"},{"id":"SUS","label":"Appeal sustained (SUS), as recorded","unit":"appeal_events","formula":null,"denominatorDefinition":null,"displayPrecision":0,"rounding":"none","methodUrl":"https://asylumcompass.com/bia-methodology"},{"id":"Other","label":"Other recorded dispositions","unit":"appeal_events","formula":null,"denominatorDefinition":null,"displayPrecision":0,"rounding":"none","methodUrl":"https://asylumcompass.com/bia-methodology"},{"id":"DIS_share","label":"Dismissed / IJ decision affirmed (DIS), as recorded","unit":"percent","formula":"100*outcome_count/same_row_n","denominatorDefinition":"same_disposition_fy_and_filing_party_n","displayPrecision":1,"rounding":"halfExpand","methodUrl":"https://asylumcompass.com/bia-methodology"},{"id":"REM_share","label":"Remanded for further action (REM), as recorded","unit":"percent","formula":"100*outcome_count/same_row_n","denominatorDefinition":"same_disposition_fy_and_filing_party_n","displayPrecision":1,"rounding":"halfExpand","methodUrl":"https://asylumcompass.com/bia-methodology"},{"id":"SUS_share","label":"Appeal sustained (SUS), as recorded","unit":"percent","formula":"100*outcome_count/same_row_n","denominatorDefinition":"same_disposition_fy_and_filing_party_n","displayPrecision":1,"rounding":"halfExpand","methodUrl":"https://asylumcompass.com/bia-methodology"},{"id":"Other_share","label":"Other recorded dispositions","unit":"percent","formula":"100*outcome_count/same_row_n","denominatorDefinition":"same_disposition_fy_and_filing_party_n","displayPrecision":1,"rounding":"halfExpand","methodUrl":"https://asylumcompass.com/bia-methodology"}],"rows":[{"id":"all:FY2021","party":"all","period":{"fy":2021,"start":"2020-10-01","end":"2021-09-30","isPartial":false,"basis":"disposition_fiscal_year"},"populationId":"bia-decided-1","sourceRef":"bia-national","provenanceId":"national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{\"fy\":2021}","n":{"state":"visible","value":18502},"outcomes":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":10087},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":4600},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":82},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":3733}},"shares":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":54.51843043995244,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":10087},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":18502}},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":24.86217706193925,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":4600},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":18502}},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":0.44319533023456925,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":82},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":18502}},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":20.17619716787374,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":3733},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":18502}}}},{"id":"all:FY2022","party":"all","period":{"fy":2022,"start":"2021-10-01","end":"2022-09-30","isPartial":false,"basis":"disposition_fiscal_year"},"populationId":"bia-decided-1","sourceRef":"bia-national","provenanceId":"national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{\"fy\":2022}","n":{"state":"visible","value":19919},"outcomes":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":9629},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":4462},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":54},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":5774}},"shares":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":48.34078015964657,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":9629},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":19919}},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":22.400722927857824,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":4462},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":19919}},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":0.2710979466840705,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":54},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":19919}},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":28.987398965811536,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":5774},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":19919}}}},{"id":"all:FY2023","party":"all","period":{"fy":2023,"start":"2022-10-01","end":"2023-09-30","isPartial":false,"basis":"disposition_fiscal_year"},"populationId":"bia-decided-1","sourceRef":"bia-national","provenanceId":"national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{\"fy\":2023}","n":{"state":"visible","value":23597},"outcomes":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":12939},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":3766},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":48},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":6844}},"shares":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":54.83324151375175,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":12939},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":23597}},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":15.959655888460398,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":3766},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":23597}},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":0.20341568843497054,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":48},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":23597}},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":29.003686909352883,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":6844},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":23597}}}},{"id":"all:FY2024","party":"all","period":{"fy":2024,"start":"2023-10-01","end":"2024-09-30","isPartial":false,"basis":"disposition_fiscal_year"},"populationId":"bia-decided-1","sourceRef":"bia-national","provenanceId":"national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{\"fy\":2024}","n":{"state":"visible","value":33160},"outcomes":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":18794},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":3753},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":45},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":10568}},"shares":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":56.6767189384801,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":18794},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":33160}},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":11.317852834740652,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":3753},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":33160}},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":0.13570566948130278,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":45},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":33160}},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":31.869722557297948,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":10568},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":33160}}}},{"id":"all:FY2025","party":"all","period":{"fy":2025,"start":"2024-10-01","end":"2025-09-30","isPartial":false,"basis":"disposition_fiscal_year"},"populationId":"bia-decided-1","sourceRef":"bia-national","provenanceId":"national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{\"fy\":2025}","n":{"state":"visible","value":24074},"outcomes":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":11978},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":3213},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":81},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":8802}},"shares":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":49.75492232283791,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":11978},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":24074}},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":13.346348757996179,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":3213},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":24074}},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":0.3364625737309961,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":81},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":24074}},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":36.56226634543491,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":8802},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":24074}}}},{"id":"A:FY2021","party":"A","period":{"fy":2021,"start":"2020-10-01","end":"2021-09-30","isPartial":false,"basis":"disposition_fiscal_year"},"populationId":"bia-respondent-decided-1","sourceRef":"bia-national","provenanceId":"national:bia-respondent-decided-1:disposition_fy:{\"fy\":2021,\"party\":\"A\"}","n":{"state":"visible","value":15234},"outcomes":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":9983},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":1745},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":7},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":3499}},"shares":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":65.53104896941053,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":9983},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":15234}},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":11.454640934751215,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":1745},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":15234}},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":0.045949849021924644,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":7},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":15234}},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":22.96836024681633,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":3499},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":15234}}}},{"id":"A:FY2022","party":"A","period":{"fy":2022,"start":"2021-10-01","end":"2022-09-30","isPartial":false,"basis":"disposition_fiscal_year"},"populationId":"bia-respondent-decided-1","sourceRef":"bia-national","provenanceId":"national:bia-respondent-decided-1:disposition_fy:{\"fy\":2022,\"party\":\"A\"}","n":{"state":"visible","value":18012},"outcomes":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":9587},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":3615},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":2},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":4808}},"shares":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":53.22562735953809,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":9587},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":18012}},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":20.069953364423718,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":3615},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":18012}},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":0.01110370863868532,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":2},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":18012}},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":26.693315567399512,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":4808},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":18012}}}},{"id":"A:FY2023","party":"A","period":{"fy":2023,"start":"2022-10-01","end":"2023-09-30","isPartial":false,"basis":"disposition_fiscal_year"},"populationId":"bia-respondent-decided-1","sourceRef":"bia-national","provenanceId":"national:bia-respondent-decided-1:disposition_fy:{\"fy\":2023,\"party\":\"A\"}","n":{"state":"visible","value":22668},"outcomes":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":12874},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":3204},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":1},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":6589}},"shares":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":56.793718016587256,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":12874},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":22668}},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":14.13446267866596,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":3204},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":22668}},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":0.0044115052055761425,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":1},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":22668}},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":29.067407799541204,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":6589},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":22668}}}},{"id":"A:FY2024","party":"A","period":{"fy":2024,"start":"2023-10-01","end":"2024-09-30","isPartial":false,"basis":"disposition_fiscal_year"},"populationId":"bia-respondent-decided-1","sourceRef":"bia-national","provenanceId":"national:bia-respondent-decided-1:disposition_fy:{\"fy\":2024,\"party\":\"A\"}","n":{"state":"visible","value":32318},"outcomes":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":18736},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":3269},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":2},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":10311}},"shares":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":57.973884522557086,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":18736},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":32318}},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":10.115106132805249,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":3269},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":32318}},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":0.006188501763723002,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":2},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":32318}},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":31.90482084287394,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":10311},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":32318}}}},{"id":"A:FY2025","party":"A","period":{"fy":2025,"start":"2024-10-01","end":"2025-09-30","isPartial":false,"basis":"disposition_fiscal_year"},"populationId":"bia-respondent-decided-1","sourceRef":"bia-national","provenanceId":"national:bia-respondent-decided-1:disposition_fy:{\"fy\":2025,\"party\":\"A\"}","n":{"state":"visible","value":21763},"outcomes":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":11793},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":1640},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":7},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":8323}},"shares":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":54.188301245232736,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":11793},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":21763}},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":7.535725773101135,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":1640},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":21763}},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":0.0321646831778707,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":7},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":21763}},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":38.24380829848826,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":8323},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":21763}}}},{"id":"I:FY2021","party":"I","period":{"fy":2021,"start":"2020-10-01","end":"2021-09-30","isPartial":false,"basis":"disposition_fiscal_year"},"populationId":"bia-decided-1","sourceRef":"bia-national","provenanceId":"national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{\"fy\":2021,\"party\":\"I\"}","n":{"state":"visible","value":3188},"outcomes":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":80},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":2814},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":71},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":223}},"shares":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":2.5094102885821834,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":80},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":3188}},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":88.2685069008783,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":2814},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":3188}},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":2.2271016311166876,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":71},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":3188}},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":6.994981179422836,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":223},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":3188}}}},{"id":"I:FY2022","party":"I","period":{"fy":2022,"start":"2021-10-01","end":"2022-09-30","isPartial":false,"basis":"disposition_fiscal_year"},"populationId":"bia-decided-1","sourceRef":"bia-national","provenanceId":"national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{\"fy\":2022,\"party\":\"I\"}","n":{"state":"visible","value":1840},"outcomes":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":37},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":814},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":47},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":942}},"shares":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":2.010869565217391,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":37},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":1840}},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":44.23913043478261,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":814},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":1840}},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":2.5543478260869565,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":47},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":1840}},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":51.19565217391305,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":942},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":1840}}}},{"id":"I:FY2023","party":"I","period":{"fy":2023,"start":"2022-10-01","end":"2023-09-30","isPartial":false,"basis":"disposition_fiscal_year"},"populationId":"bia-decided-1","sourceRef":"bia-national","provenanceId":"national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{\"fy\":2023,\"party\":\"I\"}","n":{"state":"visible","value":892},"outcomes":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":56},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":540},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":46},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":250}},"shares":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":6.278026905829597,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":56},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":892}},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":60.53811659192825,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":540},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":892}},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":5.15695067264574,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":46},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":892}},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":28.026905829596412,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":250},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":892}}}},{"id":"I:FY2024","party":"I","period":{"fy":2024,"start":"2023-10-01","end":"2024-09-30","isPartial":false,"basis":"disposition_fiscal_year"},"populationId":"bia-decided-1","sourceRef":"bia-national","provenanceId":"national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{\"fy\":2024,\"party\":\"I\"}","n":{"state":"visible","value":813},"outcomes":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":53},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":465},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":42},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":253}},"shares":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":6.519065190651906,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":53},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":813}},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":57.19557195571956,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":465},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":813}},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":5.166051660516605,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":42},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":813}},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":31.11931119311193,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":253},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":813}}}},{"id":"I:FY2025","party":"I","period":{"fy":2025,"start":"2024-10-01","end":"2025-09-30","isPartial":false,"basis":"disposition_fiscal_year"},"populationId":"bia-decided-1","sourceRef":"bia-national","provenanceId":"national:bia-decided-1:disposition_fy:{\"fy\":2025,\"party\":\"I\"}","n":{"state":"visible","value":2258},"outcomes":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":172},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":1545},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":68},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":473}},"shares":{"DIS":{"state":"visible","value":7.617360496014172,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":172},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":2258}},"REM":{"state":"visible","value":68.42338352524358,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":1545},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":2258}},"SUS":{"state":"visible","value":3.011514614703277,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":68},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":2258}},"Other":{"state":"visible","value":20.947741364038972,"reason":null,"numerator":{"state":"visible","value":473},"denominator":{"state":"visible","value":2258}}}}],"summaries":[{"party":"all","label":"All recorded filing parties","n":{"state":"visible","value":119252},"periodIds":["all:FY2021","all:FY2022","all:FY2023","all:FY2024","all:FY2025"],"formula":"sum(same_party_annual_n)","sourceRef":"bia-national"},{"party":"A","label":"Respondent-filed appeals (A)","n":{"state":"visible","value":109995},"periodIds":["A:FY2021","A:FY2022","A:FY2023","A:FY2024","A:FY2025"],"formula":"sum(same_party_annual_n)","sourceRef":"bia-national"},{"party":"I","label":"DHS-filed appeals (I)","n":{"state":"visible","value":8991},"periodIds":["I:FY2021","I:FY2022","I:FY2023","I:FY2024","I:FY2025"],"formula":"sum(same_party_annual_n)","sourceRef":"bia-national"}],"source":{"id":"bia-national","releaseId":"eoir-2026-08-bia-public-national-v1","baseReleaseId":"eoir-2026-08-court-dispositions-v5","payloadUrl":"https://asylumcompass.com/data/bia/eoir-2026-08-bia-public-national-v1/bia-national.json","payloadSha256":"b242d7073077234289a5a5c5faf07c65c19bcd4a55537b47f458172db86cb207","manifestUrl":"https://asylumcompass.com/data/bia/eoir-2026-08-bia-public-national-v1/manifest.json","manifestSha256":"005ce41913ec92a03eabb0dbc343950a5050da0fcf59a2ae6790910e197750c4","baseManifestUrl":"https://asylumcompass.com/data/eoir-2026-08-court-dispositions-v5/manifest.json","baseManifestSha256":"9d690e1de906d44cd9b1f72748f099695a1298726a4ab1c15b8905d051ec961a","officialUrl":"https://fileshare.eoir.justice.gov/EOIR%20Case%20Data.zip","sourceSha256":"0a409ce1b175532df7bb2f0c58d06dd20fa6b4d904d749fde7df1b038ac498e2","sourceSnapshot":"2026-08","dataThrough":"2026-08-31","releaseBuiltAt":"2026-10-12T04:54:29.350029+00:00","publicationDate":{"state":"unknown","reason":"not_separately_listed"},"populationVersion":"BIA1.0.0","disclosureVersion":"verified-public-counts-1","contractVersion":"bia-public-source-aggregate-1","contractSha256":"004ba5c87e7d681c47a9a97a1247e70b25ab2b141cb0d4a75f7bdfdaa348f86a","definitionContracts":{"contracts/bia-v1-2026-08.json":"98579cc86aa15a9c7f7ff0d35aead084e318e757f4eeaa95c7f1c405a71e15de","contracts/bia-v1-court-phase2a-2026-08.json":"706d5296992b130879aa23dffb11efda2ad2c17ebefc55a6e9986c0e1c9b7c5e","contracts/bia-v1-judge-phase2c-2026-08.json":"04ca292a23fd9ffc7b1147828b2820e67d00607603590375b489759704350b39","contracts/bia-v1-nationality-phase2b-2026-08.json":"223da0585e9f3187046ae2ae4091d167d29c7613b85c688f21656b82aca960b6","contracts/bia-v1-phase1-2026-08.json":"b2777bc4f12448ab81eeb93bfc88b3dbb8b6de6f8d2ec01f7c3cfcbb70e27b96"},"validationBoundary":"Validation checks the fixed published aggregate and its manifest and contracts; it does not reprocess underlying appeal records. Snapshot, cutoff, release build time and content revision are separate. A separate publication date is not listed."},"links":{"method":"https://asylumcompass.com/bia-methodology","codebook":"https://asylumcompass.com/bia-methodology#bia-codebook","sources":"https://asylumcompass.com/sources#bia-case-data","courts":"https://asylumcompass.com/courts","nationalities":"https://asylumcompass.com/nationalities","officialWorkload":"https://www.justice.gov/eoir/media/1344986/dl?inline="},"reading":{"metricResolution":"A metric combines its definition with the row’s filing party, disposition period, population ID, sourceRef and provenanceId. Summary n sums only the five published annual denominators in that same filing-party scope.","states":"Source states remain distinct: visible (published positive count), zero (real zero), suppressed (withheld by source), missing, unmatched, not_applicable, and unknown. Missing is never filled with zero; nonnumeric operands produce no numeric share. This public-source edition does not apply a site small-cell mask."},"limitations":["Official all-appeals workload covers a different population and cannot supply the denominator for these CASE IJ Case Appeal dispositions. Its numeric series, filing/followup and duration quantiles are outside this collection.","Historical court or judge code associations do not establish that the court or judge made the BIA decision. These records do not predict individual outcomes or establish causes.","Validation checks the fixed published aggregate and its manifest and contracts; it does not reprocess underlying appeal records. Snapshot, cutoff, release build time and content revision are separate. A separate publication date is not listed."],"citation":{"title":"National BIA appeal dispositions","url":"https://asylumcompass.com/bia","period":"FY2021–FY2025","timeBasis":"disposition_fiscal_year","parties":["all","A","I"],"sourceReleaseId":"eoir-2026-08-bia-public-national-v1","dataThrough":"2026-08-31"},"contentRevision":"2026-10-15"}}
```