AsylumCompass
Saved
English

This historical identity has not been confirmed. Records cannot be attributed to this person.

In FY2016, 41 of 122 asylum grant-or-denial records under judge code MT at Elizabeth were grants (33.61%) and 81 were denials (66.39%). That year, the court recorded 33.82%. EOIR data through 2026-08-31; past records do not predict an individual case.

Recorded grant share · Elizabeth · ELZ

Grants 41 · Denials 81 · N 122
95% interval: 25.84%–42.38%

Judge code MT
33.61%N 122
Elizabeth
33.82%N 553
United States · all courts
No national figure is published for this period

Among comparable judge codes at this court

Fewer than 5 judge codes at this court have 100 or more grant-or-denial records in FY2016, so no comparison among judge codes is drawn.

Record coverage
16 courts with recordsFY1994–FY2023 · 67 court-years · Courts are not pooled
Data through
2026-08-31EOIR records · not on the official listing checked 2026-09-16Data and sources

Historical outcomes by court

Each row is a fiscal year at the court stored on the dated record. Courts are not pooled; an official listing never moves old results to a new court. Small groups remain visible and are labeled.

Judge figures group saved asylum outcomes by the judge code on each EOIR proceeding. The code identifies the assigned judge; these records do not verify who personally made every application decision. How judge figures work

Recorded grant share by fiscal year at Elizabeth

0%10%20%30%40%50%FY2014FY2015FY2016FY2017FY2018FY2019FY2020FY2021FY2022FY202340.30%43.75%33.61%28.41%29.73%9.68%3.28%0.00%24.00%0.00%38.72%40.66%33.82%33.57%28.57%23.60%14.29%8.65%10.00%11.11%37.13%46.12%47.28%
  • Judge code MT
  • Elizabeth
  • United States · all courts
National figures are published for FY2021–FY2025. A broken ring marks a value from fewer than 100 records.
Recorded grant and denial outcomes · EOIR dated records
Completion FYRecorded grant shareTotal (N)Grant recordsDenial records95% interval
Elizabeth · ELZExplore this court's full context
FY20230.00%Small sample1010.00%–79.35%
FY202224.00%Small sample2561911.50%–43.43%
FY20210.00%Small sample220220.00%–14.87%
FY20203.28%Small sample612590.90%–11.19%
FY20199.68%Small sample626564.51%–19.55%
FY201829.73%Small sample37112617.49%–45.78%
FY201728.41%Small sample88256320.04%–38.58%
FY201633.61%122418125.84%–42.38%
FY201543.75%112496334.92%–52.99%
FY201440.30%Small sample67274029.39%–52.26%
FY20139.21%Small sample767694.53%–17.81%
FY20128.70%Small sample696634.05%–17.70%
FY20115.45%Small sample553521.87%–14.85%
FY201033.87%Small sample62214123.34%–46.28%
FY200919.23%Small sample52104210.80%–31.90%
FY200819.18%Small sample73145911.78%–29.66%
FY200720.48%Small sample83176613.20%–30.38%
FY200628.26%Small sample92266620.08%–38.19%
FY200515.12%Small sample8613739.05%–24.16%
FY200427.12%118328619.91%–35.77%
FY200315.97%1191910010.47%–23.59%
FY200227.21%1474010720.67%–34.92%
FY200150.29%171868542.87%–57.70%
FY200060.98%1641006453.34%–68.11%
FY199941.30%138578133.43%–49.65%
FY199831.63%Small sample98316723.27%–41.38%
FY199738.89%Small sample1871120.31%–61.38%
FY19950.00%Small sample1010.00%–79.35%
FY19940.00%Small sample1010.00%–79.35%
Newark · NEWExplore this court's full context
FY202330.00%Small sample103710.78%–60.32%
FY20110.00%Small sample1010.00%–79.35%
FY20100.00%Small sample1010.00%–79.35%
FY20080.00%Small sample4040.00%–48.99%
FY200711.11%Small sample9181.99%–43.50%
FY200611.11%Small sample9181.99%–43.50%
Philadelphia · PHIExplore this court's full context
FY20120.00%Small sample303<0.01%–56.15%
FY20110.00%Small sample1010.00%–79.35%
FY20100.00%Small sample707<0.01%–35.43%
Baltimore · BALExplore this court's full context
FY20100.00%Small sample1010.00%–79.35%
Orlando · ORLExplore this court's full context
FY20076.25%Small sample161151.11%–28.33%
FY200614.29%Small sample7162.57%–51.31%
West Los Angeles Immigration Court · WLAExplore this court's full context
FY200550.00%Small sample2119.45%–90.55%
FY200369.23%Small sample139442.37%–87.32%
Boston · BOSExplore this court's full context
FY20050.00%Small sample1010.00%–79.35%
FY200442.86%Small sample73415.82%–74.95%
FY20030.00%Small sample303<0.01%–56.15%
Detroit · DETExplore this court's full context
FY20050.00%Small sample1010.00%–79.35%
FY200350.00%Small sample63318.76%–81.24%
Guaynabo · SAJExplore this court's full context
FY200410.00%Small sample10191.79%–40.42%
FY20030.00%Small sample5050.00%–43.45%
San Francisco · SFRExplore this court's full context
FY200475.00%Small sample43130.06%–95.44%
FY200333.33%Small sample6249.68%–70.00%
Napanoch · ULSExplore this court's full context
FY200350.00%Small sample42215.00%–85.00%
FY200225.00%Small sample4134.56%–69.94%
FY200050.00%Small sample2119.45%–90.55%
FY1999100.00%Small sample11020.65%–100.00%
FY1997100.00%Small sample11020.65%–100.00%
New Orleans · NOLExplore this court's full context
FY20030.00%Small sample303<0.01%–56.15%
Atlanta – Ted Turner Drive · ATDExplore this court's full context
FY20020.00%Small sample5050.00%–43.45%
Atlanta - W. Peachtree Street · ATLExplore this court's full context
FY20020.00%Small sample2020.00%–65.76%
New York - Federal Plaza · NYCExplore this court's full context
FY20000.00%Small sample2020.00%–65.76%
FY199914.29%Small sample213184.98%–34.64%
FY199825.00%Small sample8267.15%–59.07%
FY199720.65%1843814615.43%–27.07%
FY199610.99%273302437.81%–15.25%
New York - Varick · NYVExplore this court's full context
FY199850.00%Small sample2119.45%–90.55%
FY19970.00%Small sample4040.00%–48.99%

Small sample: fewer than 100 grant or denial records. This share can swing widely.

These records do not predict an individual result or measure judge quality. A person may have more than one proceeding.

Source cutoff: 2026-08-31 · eoir-2026-08-judge-records-v2 · Source files and checks · Attribution details

Historical grant and denial records by nationality

Nationality groups count grant and denial proceedings in FY2021–FY2025, not people.

The dated results have a different coverage period and do not contain individual nationality. Small groups can change sharply.

Recorded judge × court × nationality · FY2021–FY2025 and each fiscal year
Recorded nationalityFY2021–FY2025 · pooledTotal (N)Court · same nationalityFY2025FY2024FY2023FY2022FY2021
Elizabeth
El Salvador0.00%Small sample62.61% · N 153——0 / 1—0 / 5
Guatemala0.00%Small sample55.26% · N 209———0 / 10 / 4
Mexico0.00%Small sample53.05% · N 164———0 / 30 / 2
Brazil0.00%Small sample42.00% · N 50———0 / 20 / 2
Albania100.00%Small sample260.00% · N 10———2 / 2—
Chile100.00%Small sample228.57% · N 7———2 / 2—
Colombia0.00%Small sample210.00% · N 80———0 / 10 / 1
Dominican Republic0.00%Small sample20.00% · N 123———0 / 2—
Ecuador0.00%Small sample23.03% · N 99————0 / 2
Haiti0.00%Small sample25.63% · N 71———0 / 10 / 1
Honduras0.00%Small sample24.73% · N 148————0 / 2
Trinidad And Tobago0.00%Small sample20.00% · N 10————0 / 2
Afghanistan0.00%Small sample140.00% · N 5———0 / 1—
Andorra0.00%Small sample10.00% · N 1———0 / 1—
Chad100.00%Small sample175.00% · N 12———1 / 1—
Cuba0.00%Small sample115.79% · N 19———0 / 1—
France0.00%Small sample150.00% · N 2———0 / 1—
Georgia0.00%Small sample121.43% · N 14———0 / 1—
Germany0.00%Small sample10.00% · N 5———0 / 1—
Ghana100.00%Small sample125.00% · N 16———1 / 1—
Grenada0.00%Small sample10.00% · N 1————0 / 1
Italy0.00%Small sample10.00% · N 1———0 / 1—
Jamaica0.00%Small sample11.85% · N 54———0 / 1—
Nigeria0.00%Small sample13.03% · N 33———0 / 1—
Newark
Ecuador0.00%Small sample719.15% · N 2,475——0 / 7——
Haiti100.00%Small sample248.18% · N 110——2 / 2——
Chile100.00%Small sample161.54% · N 26——1 / 1——

Small sample: fewer than 100 grant or denial records. This share can swing widely. Each fiscal year shows grants / N; — means no grant or denial record that year.

Judge means the code saved on the proceeding, not independently verified decision authorship. Flags are visual aids for mapped source categories; historical, unknown and non-geographic categories remain text-only.

EOIR CASE nationality aggregates · eoir-2026-08-nationality-complete-v1 · Download complete counts

Hearing schedule

One proceeding record is not necessarily a separate hearing session.

Baltimore · BAL · All proceedings · 2026-09–2029-08

Asylum-associated records are a subset of All proceedings.

Schedule display range: 2026-09–2029-08 (36 months)

Historical schedule records exist, but no future hearing date is recorded for this selection in this edition.

Atlanta – Ted Turner Drive · ATD

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

Atlanta - W. Peachtree Street · ATL

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

Baltimore · BAL

Historical schedule records exist, but no future hearing date is recorded for this selection in this edition.

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

Boston · BOS

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

Buffalo · BUF

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

Detroit · DET

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

Elizabeth · ELZ

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

Harlingen · HLG

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

Newark · NEW

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

New Orleans · NOL

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

New York - Federal Plaza · NYC

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

New York - Varick · NYV

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

Orlando · ORL

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

Philadelphia · PHI

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

Guaynabo · SAJ

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

San Francisco · SFR

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

Napanoch · ULS

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

West Los Angeles Immigration Court · WLA

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0Source files and checks

Dated result records

Nationality and representation selections do not filter this list. Case identifiers and personal attributes are not included.

Results for the current selection

Loading associated results…

These dates belong to proceedings associated with the recorded judge code. They do not establish when that person served or who made the application decision.

Monthly record distribution for this selection

Filtered records by court and fiscal year

All eight saved result categories · same filters as the result list
Historical record courtFiscal yearGrantedDeniedRecorded as abandonedRecorded as withdrawnRecorded as not adjudicatedRecorded as administratively closedOther recorded categoriesNo application result recordedTotal records

Each row totals its eight categories using the current filters. Fiscal years run from 10-01 through 09-30.

One row per eligible proceeding · latest completion date first
Proceeding completion dateHistorical record courtSaved application result

Counts use stored proceeding completion dates and judge codes. Later source releases may revise earlier records.

Source cutoff: 2026-08-31 · eoir-2026-08-judge-records-v2 · Source files and checks

Recorded BIA appeals associated with this judge code

These records are linked to proceedings carrying this EOIR judge code in the 2026-08 source snapshot. The data do not establish that the coded judge personally issued the decision under BIA review.

Historical decision FY2021–FY2025 pooled · respondent-filed appeals (A)

Denominator: respondent-filed BIA IJ Case Appeal events with an exact proceeding link and stored judge code, with a recorded disposition during the displayed period.

Respondent-filed recorded BIA appeal events during FY2021–FY2025
Appeal events (denominator)DIS · recorded dismissal/affirmanceREM · remand as recordedSUS · appeal sustained as recordedOther · mixed recorded dispositions
975525017

Small sample: N is below 100. Counts remain visible; a few events can change the pattern substantially.

Questions about these records

Is this the judge’s asylum approval or denial rate?

It is the recorded grant share: of 122 asylum grant-or-denial records under judge code MT at Elizabeth in FY2016, 41 were grants (33.61%) and 81 were denials (66.39%).

Withdrawals, abandonment, administrative closure and other outcomes are outside this denominator. The judge code identifies the assigned judge; it does not prove who decided each application.

Why do other websites show a different number?

Publications count different things. This page counts asylum applications that ended in a grant or a denial in EOIR’s public CASE data, by fiscal year, at the court stored on each proceeding, and never pools courts.

Other reports may count other relief, such as withholding of removal or protection under the Convention Against Torture, count decisions rather than proceedings, combine courts or use other years. Compare the period, the population and N before comparing percentages.

Why are courts listed separately?

Each record keeps the court stored on its proceeding. This judge code has grant or denial records at 16 courts. They are shown separately and never pooled, and the official listing does not move older records to a new court.

What does a small sample mean here?

When fewer than 100 grant or denial records stand behind a share, one or two decisions can move it by several percentage points. Such figures are marked † or labeled as a small sample, and the 95% interval shows how wide the uncertainty is.

Can these numbers predict my case?

No. They describe past records under a judge code. The outcome of a case depends on its own facts, evidence and law. For advice about your case, talk to a qualified lawyer or accredited representative.

Data and sources

Source cutoff: · eoir-2026-08-judge-source-coverage-v1

Dated asylum records and recorded grants or denials are available by court and fiscal year.

Result record coverage

24,247Associated proceeding records
4,938Proceedings linked to asylum applications
4,931Eligible dated asylum records
2,863Dated grant or denial records

All courts and all stored dates in this source edition. These coverage counts do not change with the result-list filters.

Historical record courts
17
Earliest recorded completion FY
FY1994
Latest recorded completion FY
FY2023
Why some source records are outside the dated results
  • 48 eligible asylum records have no application result; 48 of them appear in the dated list.
  • 6 asylum-linked proceedings are outside the included proceeding types.
  • 1 asylum-linked proceedings have conflicting saved application results.

A blank date or result does not establish a pending case, an undecided application, or the absence of a decision. Missing dates are not assigned to an assumed fiscal year.

All eligible dated result categories are included through the source cutoff, without aggregate suppression filters.

Source cutoff: 2026-08-31 · FY2026 is incomplete. Earlier stored dates may predate a judge’s appointment because assignment and saved completion date describe different events.

Nationality and representation selections do not filter this list. Case identifiers and personal attributes are not included.

Available historical coverage

Source coverage includes all normalized dated records for this identity. It is not verified decision authorship or a complete case history.

Coverage counting rules

Counts describe stored proceedings associated with the judge code, not unique cases, people, or verified decision authorship. Asylum applications are combined per proceeding using the same joins and conflict rules as the dated list.

4,931 asylum-linked proceedings meet the proceeding-type, case-link and result-consistency rules. These eligible records split into missing dates, invalid dates, dates after the cutoff, and dated records through the cutoff.

The dated list includes all saved result categories, including a blank result. Grant share uses only dated grants divided by dated grants plus denials; other categories are excluded.

These are saved results on proceedings assigned to the selected judge in EOIR data, not independently verified decision authorship. The application result has no separate decision timestamp. Completion dates may reflect a different event or later edits.

Each row represents one eligible proceeding after duplicate application rows are combined. Identical dates and results can appear multiple times. A person may have multiple proceedings. Within-day order does not indicate the sequence of decisions.

The public timeline includes all eight saved result categories and all stored completion years through the source cutoff. Conflicting application outcomes and inconsistent case joins remain excluded. Complete records can reconstruct counts hidden in legacy aggregate tables; those tables no longer provide a non-reconstruction guarantee.

Official court listing

Directory checked: EOIR hearing directory

Not on the checked official listing

The checked listing does not establish why this name is absent or where this person works now.

Hearing schedule sources

Schedule filtering and source checks

The 2026-08 EOIR edition is grouped using a source cutoff of 2026-08-31. Counts describe proceeding records with retained future hearing dates, grouped by the judge and court codes stored on each schedule record. Records with a handling reason and other excluded records are kept outside the counts; records that cannot be confirmed are listed separately. All proceedings includes the reliably identified asylum-associated subset.

Later recorded hearing dates are included in the source coverage summary.

All proceedings · future hearing dates through 2036-08-31

These source coverage counts include all proceedings and do not change with the proceedings filter above.

Atlanta – Ted Turner Drive

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
24
Other schedule types
24
Reliable asylum association
24

Atlanta - W. Peachtree Street

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
6
Other schedule types
6
Reliable asylum association
6

Baltimore

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
2
Reliable asylum association
1
No identifiable asylum association
1

Boston · BOS

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
160
Other schedule types
160
Reliable asylum association
70
No identifiable asylum association
90

Buffalo

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
51
Other schedule types
30
No identifiable asylum association
51

Detroit

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
117
Other schedule types
116
Reliable asylum association
52
No identifiable asylum association
65

Elizabeth

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
72,066
Other schedule types
27,207
Reliable asylum association
22,535
No identifiable asylum association
49,504
Unlinked asylum records
27

Harlingen

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
1,479
Other schedule types
1,413
Reliable asylum association
5
No identifiable asylum association
1,474

Newark

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
1,227
Other schedule types
261
Reliable asylum association
517
No identifiable asylum association
710

New Orleans · NOL

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
59
Other schedule types
59
Reliable asylum association
12
No identifiable asylum association
47

New York - Federal Plaza

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
3,752
Other schedule types
3,737
Reliable asylum association
2,907
No identifiable asylum association
845

New York - Varick

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
34
Other schedule types
34
Reliable asylum association
32
No identifiable asylum association
2

Orlando

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
179
Other schedule types
179
Reliable asylum association
126
No identifiable asylum association
53

Philadelphia

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
30
Reliable asylum association
20
No identifiable asylum association
10

Guaynabo · SAJ

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
68
Other schedule types
68
Reliable asylum association
51
No identifiable asylum association
17

San Francisco · SFR

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
53
Other schedule types
53
Reliable asylum association
50
No identifiable asylum association
3

Napanoch · ULS

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
68
Other schedule types
68
Reliable asylum association
43
No identifiable asylum association
25

West Los Angeles Immigration Court · WLA

Retained: 0Excluded: 0Unable to confirm: 0

Raw Master and Individual records
0
Unconfirmed proportion
Not calculable
Historical schedule records
191
Other schedule types
191
Reliable asylum association
183
No identifiable asylum association
8
View schedule counting rules
Source files, versions and checks

BIA appeal sources

BIA scope and counting rules

These are historical pooled counts, not a judge score or a current pattern. This product has no annual judge-code breakdown. DIS does not prove this judge was affirmed; REM is not an asylum grant; SUS is not a final asylum outcome.

Recorded BIA disposition patterns can change over time. These FY2021–FY2025 counts are not a permanent characteristic of this judge code. Changes may coincide with law, policy, administration, BIA composition, case mix or backlog; these descriptive data do not establish a cause.

All-party source coverage is separate from the respondent-filed table. National parent appeal events: 119,252 · Linked to a stored judge code: 119,155.

Respondent-filed source events: 109,995 · Linked to a stored judge code: 109,915 · Published respondent-filed events: 67,156 · Respondent-filed events with identity limitations: 42,759.

Judge code: MT · Stored source field: B_TblProceeding.IJ_CODE · Population: bia-decided-stored-judge-chronology-clean-1.

Disposition date basis: tblAppeal.datBIADecision · Historical period: 2020-10-01–2025-09-30 · Source cutoff: 2026-08-31.

The stored code is an association in the snapshot, not proof of decision authorship or assignment when the original decision was issued. Today’s judge directory and court listing describe current context only.

Source versions and checks

Coverage and source versions are listed separately from publication, acquisition and later checks. A check does not extend the records beyond their cutoff.

EOIR public CASE data

Used on this page: Dated results, historical outcomes and saved hearing schedules

Historical result coverageFY1994–FY2023

Source edition2026-08

Source snapshot cutoff

The first and last available fiscal years bound this range; intervening years may have no records. Saved hearing dates and BIA disposition periods have separate coverage.

Standard comparison periodFY2021–FY2025

Source obtained or reviewed for this edition

Official source recheck ·

Source reachable at the last check; its contents have not been compared with this edition yet

Cite this page AsylumCompass. “Mirlande Tadal (MT): historical immigration judge code records.” https://asylumcompass.com/judge/mirlande-tadal-mt Include the source edition and period of the figure you cite.

Continue from this judge